Sending a counterproposal (CP41)

Updated 2026-11-18

A counterproposal (CP41) responds to a contract that's already out with different terms — a different price, closing date, or any other negotiated point. This article covers how to start and submit one in Done-Deal.

When you can counter

A counter can only be created once the parent contract has been sent — you can't counter a draft that hasn't gone out yet. Look for the Propose counter link in the contract's toolbar; it only appears while the contract is in sent status.

If your buyers already signed and the offer shows Awaiting seller, a CP41 cannot change it. Close the offer, copy it, change the terms and send the copy for signature. To change an executed contract, use Amend or extend.

Clicking it creates a new CP41 draft linked to that parent contract.

When the listing agent counters from CTM

When the listing agent sends a counter from CTM eContracts (CTM), the seller has usually signed it already. Your buyers accept it by signing it. You do not close your offer or write a new one.

This note is being turned on one brokerage at a time. Until it is on for yours, the transaction page shows the older "came in by email" note, and you sign the counter from its card on Home.

When it is on, you may see these notes at the top of the transaction page:

  • A counter came in on this offer, with when it arrived. Click Review and sign the counter to open its signing card on the same page, then add your buyers and click Start Signing. You do not sign a counter yourself: only the buyers and sellers do. Check the signature boxes, then click Save & send signing link to send your buyers their link. If there is no button, open the counter under Forms & Documents to start signing.
  • Counter: waiting on the people on your side who have not signed yet.
  • The counter is signed. The signed copy is being made. Nothing to do yet.
  • The counter is signed. Check the dates and price the counter changed, then click Set the deal dates so the deadlines start.

Note: Do not upload a counter on the contract page as the seller-signed copy. Your buyers sign it from the transaction page.

If the counter came to your own email

If the listing agent sent the counter to your own email instead, forward that email to the transaction's Done-Deal address. A CTM email with only a link works too: Done-Deal fetches the counter from the link. Forward it from the email you sign in with, or from an address under Settings → Profile → Other emails I use.

Done-Deal files the counter on the transaction and makes its signing card, the same as a counter sent straight to Done-Deal. The email you get says Review and sign the counter, and the counter's row under Forms & Documents has a Review and sign button. Both open the signing card.

Done-Deal makes the signing card only when your buyers' offer is signed and was sent to the listing agent. If it was not, the counter is still filed, and a card on Home says why it is not set up for signing. Sign and send your offer first, then ask the listing agent to send the counter again.

When the deal goes under contract by itself

This is also being turned on one brokerage at a time. Until it is on for yours, you set the deal dates yourself, as above.

When it is on, Done-Deal puts the deal under contract once both of these are true:

  • the seller signed the counter before it was sent to you, and your buyers have now signed it;
  • the signed copy has gone back to the listing agent (by email, and to their CTM when Done-Deal has their CTM address).

Done-Deal then:

  1. Sets the deal's price, earnest money and closing date from the counter.
  2. Sets the MEC date to the day the signed copy went back (Colorado time).
  3. Marks your buyers' offer executed. The executed copy is one PDF: your buyers' signed offer, followed by the signed counter.
  4. Builds the deadlines, using any deadline the counter changed, and moves the deal to Under Contract.
  5. Sends your buyers their copy.

Your buyers' signed offer itself is never changed. Check the dates afterward: Done-Deal cannot read a deadline row marked Deleted with a checkbox on a printed counter.

You may also see these notes instead:

  • Did the seller sign it before sending it to you? Done-Deal could not see the seller's signature on the counter. Open the counter and look. If the seller signed it, click Yes, the seller signed. Put this deal under contract. If the seller has not signed, do not click it: the counter is not accepted until the seller signs.
  • Done-Deal could not read all of its terms. Nothing changed. Set the deal dates and price from the counter. Done-Deal only uses a price or date it can match to its row on the counter, so you will see this often.
  • Done-Deal could not confirm the signed copy reached the listing agent. Nothing changed. Make sure they have it, then set the deal dates.
  • Done-Deal could not finish putting this deal under contract. The deal may already show the counter's price and dates, but your buyers' offer is not executed yet. Click Try again.

When you counter an offer on your listing

On a listing, you counter a buyer's offer from its card: click Counter, change only what the sellers counter, set when the counter expires, and confirm who signs for the sellers. Done-Deal sends the counter to the sellers to sign.

Under the form there is a tick box: Send it to (the buyer's agent's name) as soon as every seller signs. It is ticked to start.

  • Ticked: when the last seller signs, Done-Deal sends the counter to the buyer's agent for you. You get an alert that says The sellers signed. Your counter is on its way to the buyer's agent. You do not need to come back and click Send. If the send then fails, Done-Deal alerts you or shows the send in red on the offer card.
  • Not ticked: when the last seller signs, you get an alert. Open the offer card and click Send counter to (the buyer's agent's name).

Even with the tick, Done-Deal does not send the counter on its own when:

  • the counter expired before the last seller signed;
  • another offer on the same listing has an open counter. The alert says Another counter is open on this listing. Check it, then click Send.;
  • the listing already has an accepted offer or is no longer listed.

Then the alert says why, and the Send counter to button is still on the offer card.

The tick box only shows when Done-Deal has the buyer's agent's email. Without it, send the counter through CTM. The tick box is being turned on one brokerage at a time. Until it is on for yours, you click Send counter to after the sellers sign.

On desktop

Desktop opens the counter directly in the full on-screen editor — the same one described in Filling out a contract — pre-loaded with the CP41 form. Edit any field the same way you would on an original contract, and the same autosave and blue-ink rules apply.

Download PDF and Print in the header give you the filled-in counter at any time. Both save your changes first.

When you're ready, click Send for signature in the header. If anything required is still missing, Done-Deal shows you exactly what's needed before it will send.

On mobile

On a phone-sized screen, Done-Deal uses a guided three-step wizard instead of the full form, since the complete CP41 grid is hard to use on a small screen:

  1. Review — confirm the parent contract's current terms before you propose changes.
  2. Propose your changes — edit the fields most commonly negotiated in a counter: purchase price, earnest money, closing date, possession date and time, inclusions, exclusions, and additional provisions or contingencies. A live "What's changing" panel shows every edit as you make it. Anything less common can be added under Other terms by field key.
  3. Confirm — review the full list of changes one more time, then submit.

Note: The mobile wizard only exposes the most commonly negotiated fields directly. For anything else, switch to a desktop browser to edit the full form.

What gets submitted

Done-Deal only submits the fields you actually changed — not the entire contract again. Everything you don't touch carries over unchanged from the parent. This keeps the counter focused on what's actually being negotiated and keeps the audit trail clean.

Submitting creates a new CP41 draft contract. It doesn't go out automatically — you still review it in the editor and click Send for signature when you're ready.

FAQ

Can I counter a counter?

Yes. Once your CP41 has been sent, the same Propose counter link becomes available on it, letting either side counter again.

Where do I see what changed in a counterproposal?

Every counter appears as a "Counter-Proposed" event in contract history, with the specific field-by-field changes available to expand.

Why won't Done-Deal send my counterproposal because of a deadline?

Done-Deal checks the dates the contract will have after the counter: each new date on the CP41, and the deal's current date for every row you left blank. The Inspection Termination, Appraisal and New Loan Availability Deadlines must each fall at least one day before the closing date. Move the deadline earlier or the closing date later. A row marked Deleted is not checked.

What if the parent contract hasn't been sent yet?

You can't create a counterproposal until the parent contract is sent. Send or finish the original contract first.

Related articles

Still stuck?

Email support@done-deal.co and a real person will get back to you — usually the same business day.